Lab study suggests those who survive breakthrough COVID-19 infection may have ‘super immunity’
Alexandra Mae JonesCTVNews.ca writer
@AlexandraMaeJ ContactPublished Sunday, December 19, 2021 12:29PM ESThttps://imasdk.googleapis.com/js/core/bridge3.493.0_en.html#goog_2003535366Volume 90% COVID-19 overwhelming testing centres NOW PLAYINGBecause of COVID-19, CEO of the Medical Laboratory Professionals Association of Ontario Michelle Hoad says testing centres are overwhelmed.CTV National News: The season of Omicron NOW PLAYINGHeather Butts takes a look at the current situation across Canada as provinces try to contain the spread of the Omicron variant.CTV National News: New COVID-19 restrictions NOW PLAYINGSix provinces are implementing new COVID-19 measures to stop the spread of the Omicron variant. John Vennavally-Rao has the details.Dr. Labos: Cases ‘trending in the wrong direction’ NOW PLAYINGDr. Christopher Labos discusses new COVID-19 measures in Ontario, as the province reports highest case count in more than seven months.‘Let’s use everything at our disposal’: Bogoch NOW PLAYINGInfectious disease specialist Dr. Isaac Bogoch says several layers of protection will be needed to mitigate the impact of Omicron.Dr. Brown on why he’s not recommending a lockdown NOW PLAYINGDr. Adalsteinn Brown, the head of Ontario’s science table, explains why he is not recommending a lockdown at this time.Even best case scenarios are ‘bleak’: Dr. Brown NOW PLAYINGThe latest COVID-19 modelling is predicting some of the worst outcomes of the entire pandemic as Omicron fuels an infection surge.Omicron transmits ‘incredibly fast’: Dr. Brown NOW PLAYINGDr. Adalsteinn Brown says serious restrictions that reduce contacts will be needed to blunt the Omicron wave.How will Ontario’s new COVID-19 plan affect you? NOW PLAYINGAkshay Tandon outlines Ontario’s new COVID-19 measures which includes expanding booster eligibility and slashing capacity limits.CTV National News: Booster program expands NOW PLAYINGOntario is expanding its COVID-19 booster program as the Omicron variant spreads. Vanessa Lee reports.‘Call to arms’ in Ont. in response to Omicron NOW PLAYINGThe Ontario government is launching a blitz to expand rapid testing access, booster shot eligibility and reimposing some capacity limits.Dec. 15: Ont. officials expand booster eligibility NOW PLAYINGDec. 15: The Ontario government announced they are expanding the COVID-19 vaccine booster eligibility to every adult in the province.‘We’re all tired’: Ford on new booster eligibility NOW PLAYINGOnt. Premier Doug Ford and the province’s health minister announce that anyone 18 years or older will soon be able to get a booster shot.Update on COVID-19 booster strategy coming NOW PLAYINGOntario Premier Doug Ford is expected to provide an update into the province’s COVID-19 booster vaccine strategy.CTV National News: Reimposing health measures NOW PLAYINGSome provinces reintroduced measures to slow the spread of the Omicron variant as cases rise.Schools ‘first to open, last to close’: Dr. Moore NOW PLAYINGOntario’s Dr. Kieron Moore addresses the potential shut down of schools after the holidays amid fears of the spread of the Omicron variant.Doctor: Expecting ‘rapid rise’ in Omicron cases NOW PLAYINGDr. Barry Nathanson says more restrictions, rapid testing and boosters are all needed to keep Omicron cases under control.Omicron rapidly becoming dominant strain in Ont. NOW PLAYINGOntario’s top doctor says the province can’t take any chances as Omicron rapidly becomes the dominant strain.Dec. 14: Ont. update on COVID-19 situation NOW PLAYINGDec. 14: Officials provide an update on the COVID-19 situation in Ontario as Omicron variant cases are still on the rise.Every case may be Omicron end of Dec.: Dr. Moore NOW PLAYINGDr. Kieran Moore says Omicron is expected to be 100 per cent of COVID-19 cases in Ontario by the end of December.Ont. ‘planning for the worst’ with Omicron NOW PLAYINGOntario Chief Medical Officer of Health Dr. Kieran Moore says Ontario is ‘planning for the worst’ with Omicron even if it’s less severe.Ont. enhances restrictions in long-term care homes NOW PLAYINGOntario’s top doctor announced enhanced measures including mandatory vaccinations and regular COVID-19 testing in long-term care homes.Ont. moves to limit rise of Omicron variant NOW PLAYINGOntario announced modest measures in response to a surge of COVID-19 cases in the province amid an escalation of Omicron cases.Ont. strengthens proof of vaccination requirements NOW PLAYINGOntario’s CMOH Dr. Kieran Moore introduced new measures to strengthen the province’s proof of vaccination requirements.Ont. announces proof of vaccination system changes NOW PLAYINGOntario Health Minister Christine Elliott announces changes to the province’s proof of vaccination system in response to rising cases.‘We need to be up for the new challenge’: Dr. Juni NOW PLAYINGScientific director of Ontario’s COVID-19 Science Advisory Table Dr. Peter Juni responds to the province’s recent rise in COVID-19 cases.Omicron may be dominant strain soon: Dr. Moore NOW PLAYINGOntario’s Chief Medical Officer of Health Dr. Kieran Moore revealed 10 per cent of COVID-19 samples in the province are the Omicron variant.Moving towards QR vaccination codes NOW PLAYINGDr. Isaac Bogoch shares his concerns about moving to QR vaccinations codes in Ontario.CTV National News: Push to accelerate rapid tests NOW PLAYINGOntario and Quebec reported a significant bump in new COVID-19 cases. Genevieve Beauchemin explains.Ont. considering new COVID-19 measures NOW PLAYINGThe Ontario government is mulling various new measures and restrictions in response to a sharp rise in daily COVID-19 cases.How rapid tests in schools will make a difference NOW PLAYINGDr. Peter Juni discusses the significance of getting rapid tests in elementary schools.Rapid tests not replacement for PCR: doctor NOW PLAYINGDr. Jason Kindrachuck speaks about the need of identify COVID-19 cases quickly to cut transmission chains.Should rapid tests be free? NOW PLAYINGDr. Fahad Razak explains the benefits of rapid tests and when it should be used.Ont. facing pressure to expand rapid test access NOW PLAYINGThe Ford government is facing pressure from critics to expand access for a free COVID-19 rapid test.Ford defends Ont.’s strategy for rapid testing NOW PLAYINGThe Ontario government is defending their strategy for issuing rapid tests amid concerns over its distribution criteria.Furness: Omicron pleas ‘falling on deaf ears’ NOW PLAYINGEpidemiologist Colin Furness says with the advent of Omicron, the government needs to recognize the airborne transmission of COVID-19.CTV National News: Ontario COVID modelling NOW PLAYINGNew modelling suggests Ontario hospitals could be under strain due to infection numbers rising. Heather Wright reports.Ontario COVID-19 cases, hospitalizations to rise NOW PLAYINGCTV’s Katie Griffin reports on the new COVID-19 modelling data in Ontario, and the decision to pause the reopening plan.Dr. Moore on indefinite pause of reopening plan NOW PLAYINGOntario’s Chief Medical Officer of Health Dr. Kieran Moore explains why Ontario is indefinitely pausing its reopening plan.Growing calls to increase rapid testing NOW PLAYINGPharmacist Kristen Watt speaks about the overflow of rapids test they have on hand and the need to get them into the hands of the public.Ont. ICUs could see Delta-fuelled surge: modelling NOW PLAYINGNew COVID-19 modelling in Ontario suggests Ontario can see as many as 200 to 400 people in ICUs due to the Delta variant.Ont. expands eligibility for third COVID-19 dose NOW PLAYINGThe Ontario government is turning to COVID-19 vaccinations to protect residents amid fears of the Omicron variant in the province.Ontario bracing for more Omicron cases NOW PLAYINGWhile the spread of the new Omicron variant in Ontario is worrisome, experts say supressing the Delta variant has to be prioritized.Ont. expands booster shot eligibility NOW PLAYINGThe Ontario government is expanding third dose eligibility to residents aged 50 and older amid concerns about the Omicron variant.How should we pronounce ‘Omicron’? NOW PLAYINGA linguist breaks down the debate over pronouncing ‘Omicron’ and whether it’s ‘ah-muh-cron’ or closer to how the ancient Greeks said it.When will all adults be able to get a third dose? NOW PLAYINGOntario’s Chief Medical Officer of Health Dr. Kieran Moore explains when all adults in the province will be eligible for a third dose.‘Paying close attention’ to Omicron: Dr. Moore NOW PLAYINGOnt. Chief Medical Officer of Health Dr. Moore says he expects vaccines to still provide a measure of protection against Omicron.How will boosters be rolled out? NOW PLAYINGDr. Tasleem Nimjee weighs in on what the policy will be surrounding boosters.Ontario standing behind vaccination and testing NOW PLAYINGOnt. Premier Doug Ford speaks to reporters about efforts to combat COVID-19 in wake of Omicron variant.Ford says Ont. increasing testing amid new variant NOW PLAYINGOntario Premier Doug Ford says the province will increase testing and contact tracing in response to the new Omicron variant.Ford praises Canada’s new travel restrictions NOW PLAYINGPremier Doug Ford says his government is closely monitoring the spread of the new Omicron variant.Omicron variant in Ottawa: What does that mean? NOW PLAYINGTwo cases confirmed, two more under investigation, CTV’s Colton Praill tells us what we know about the variant.Nov. 29: Moore calls for calm over Omicron NOW PLAYINGOntario’s chief medical officer of health says the province is looking at additional measures in response to Omicron.Nov. 29: Ont. residents urged to remain vigilant NOW PLAYINGDr. Kieran Moore says Ontario is prepared to respond to this and other variants.
A new study that tested live SARS-CoV-2 against blood samples in a laboratory setting is suggesting that those who survive a breakthrough infection may have some sort of ‘super immunity’ against variants.
The study, which was published Thursday in the Journal of the American Medical Association, focused on how those with breakthrough infections had a subsequent strong immune response against the Delta variant, which researchers believe is an indication that there will be a strong response against other variants as well.
“We have not examined the Omicron variant specifically, but based on the results of this study we would anticipate that breakthrough infections from the Omicron variant will generate a similarly strong immune response among vaccinated people,” Fikadu Tafesse, assistant professor of molecular microbiology and immunology at the Oregon Health & Science University (OHSU) and senior author of the study, said in a press release.
Researchers used live SARS-CoV-2 variants to test against blood serum from 26 people who came down with COVID-19 after being vaccinated, as well as 26 vaccinated people without breakthrough infections who served as a control group.
What they found was that the level of antibodies in those who had breakthrough cases was higher and more effective than the antibodies generated two weeks after receiving a second dose of the Pfizer vaccine.
The antibodies were as much as 1000 per cent more effective in those with breakthrough infections, the release said.
“You can’t get a better immune response than this,” Tafesse said. “These vaccines are very effective against severe disease. Our study suggests that individuals who are vaccinated and then exposed to a breakthrough infection have super immunity.”
Participants were recruited from fully vaccinated health-care workers at OHSU between January and August, and the control group was age and gender matched to those with breakthrough infections.
Researchers then exposed the blood samples of those participants to live virus in a lab and compared the antibody response between the control group and those with breakthrough infections.
Out of the breakthrough cases, 10 cases were Delta, nine were non-Delta cases such as Alpha or the original strain, while seven were unknown variants. Those with breakthrough cases of Delta were found to have an improved potency of antibodies against further Delta infection compared to those with breakthrough cases of non-Delta variants.
These results don’t mean that someone should seek out a breakthrough infection. People who get breakthrough infections do still have a small chance of developing severe disease or even death, a chance that is higher if they are older, immunocompromised, or have other risk factors. People with breakthrough infections can also spread the virus, potentially endangering others who are at a higher risk or are unvaccinated.
Researchers say that the results highlight the importance of getting vaccinated.
“The key is to get vaccinated,” Dr. Marcel Curlin, associate professor of medicine (infectious diseases) in the OHSU School of Medicine and a co-author of the research, said in the release. “You’ve got to have a foundation of protection.”
He added that as more people get vaccinated, these results could indicate how protection will add up with time.
“I think this speaks to an eventual end game,” he said. “It doesn’t mean we’re at the end of the pandemic, but it points to where we’re likely to land: Once you’re vaccinated and then exposed to the virus, you’re probably going to be reasonably well-protected from future variants.
“Our study implies that the long-term outcome is going to be a tapering-off of the severity of the worldwide epidemic.”